Outside/In

A show where curiosity and the natural world collide

  • Home
  • About
    • Team
    • Media Kit
    • Get in touch
  • Episodes
    • Episodes
    • Listening Recs
  • Series
    • Operation Night Cat
    • What Remains
    • The Underdogs
    • Yardwork
    • Windfall
    • Powerline
    • Patient Zero
    • Book Club
  • Patreon
  • Donate

A wild coho salmon caught by host Nate Hegyi. Credit: Nate Hegyi

Is the wild-caught salmon on your plate actually wild?

November 18, 2026 by Nate Hegyi

While fishing the rainy shores of Juneau, Alaska, host Nate Hegyi starts questioning the origins of the salmon filling his freezer. A behind-the-scenes tour of a salmon hatchery reveals a surprising truth: many "wild-caught" Pacific salmon actually begin their lives inside cold, dark warehouses.

Through a decades-old practice known as ocean ranching, workers mix eggs and milt in five-gallon buckets, shelter the hatchlings from predators, and release them into the sea—giving these "silver-spoon" fish a massive survival boost before they're caught by commercial fleets or lured back up concrete fish ladders.

Even though ocean-ranched salmon spend most of their lives in the open ocean, they occupy a murky middle ground between truly wild fish and industrial aquaculture.

Featuring Ryley Oliver and Ian Urbina

 
 
 

ADDITIONAL MATERIALS
A review of peer-reviewed literature found that hatchery-born salmon and trout had adverse impacts on their wildborne counterparts. 

Check out Ian Urbina’s wide-ranging investigation into fishmeal here. 

SUPPORT

To share your questions and feedback with Outside/In, call the show’s hotline and leave us a voicemail. The number is 1-844-GO-OTTER. No question is too serious or too silly.

Outside/In is made possible with listener support. Click here to join our Patreon and get ad-free episodes of the podcast.

Follow Outside/In on Instagram, TikTok, or join our private discussion group on Facebook.

CREDITS
Host: Nate Hegyi

Reported and mixed by Nate Hegyi

Editing by Taylor Quimby.

Our staff also includes Marina Henke, Justine Paradis, Felix Poon and Jessica Hunt

Taylor Quimby is NHPR’s Director of Podcasts

Music by Lennon Hutton, Sulu, Blue Saga, Rebecca Mardal, Jake and Jake, Jobi, Hennie Hun, Franzi, and Beyza.

Outside/In is a production of New Hampshire Public Radio


download a transcript

Audio Transcript

Note: Episodes of Outside/In are made as pieces of audio, and some context and nuance may be lost on the page. Transcripts are generated using a combination of speech recognition software and human transcribers, and may contain errors.

Nate Hegyi: From NHPR, This is Outside/In, a show where curiosity and the natural world collide. I’m your host, Nate Hegyi.

It’s another rainy day in Juneau, Alaska. Every day, after work, I like to go fishing for salmon. <<squish in mud>> gosh dangit, that’s a lot of mud.

<<casting, plop of spinner, reeling in, nat sound underneath all of this going forward>>

Nate Hegyi: This is my happy place. On the shore of a lagoon… a cold nip in the air… casting for salmon.

I’m trying to squeeze in as much “Nate” time as possible these days because LIFE ALERT. I’m about to become a dad.

I will also, heads up, be away from the show for a couple months on paternity leave.

But right now… I’m just soaking in those last little bits of alone time… fishing for salmon.

<<another cast, reel in>>

Nate Hegyi: I’ve been lucky to be able to fill my freezer with wild-caught Alaskan salmon this fall. This is like the creme-de-la-creme of salmon. The kind that would cost you $40 a pound at Whole Foods in Boston.

They have really cool names like Coho, Chinook and Sockeye. I can get dozens of them for the cost of a fishing license and some lures.

<<Cast again>>

Nate Hegyi: But lately there has been something bothering me about my wild-caught Alaskan salmon.

Mainly… that it might not actually be so wild.

Today on the show, we journey into the wild… well I guess maybe not-so-wild… world of something called ocean ranching.

And how that fresh-caught Alaskan salmon you might buy at a fancy restaurant may have been born inside of a warehouse.

Stick around

###

Nate Hegyi: From NHPR, this is Outside/In. I’m Nate Hegyi.

A few weeks ago, I went on a tour of the MacCauley Salmon Hatchery in Juneau, Alaska. From the outside, it looks like a high school perched on the banks of a wide ocean channel.

I was there to see some salmon… but the first animals I actually saw… were seals.

Nate Hegyi: Hey, there's a seal.

Ryley Oliver: One of many. Um, last year we had a mama seal and a baby that we named Cookie and Cupcake.

Nate Hegyi: That’s my tour guide… Ryley Oliver.

Ryley Oliver: So this might be one of the returners.

Nate Hegyi: And so why are they hanging out here?

Ryley Oliver: Uh, we have so many harbor seals and Steller sea lions that hang out here specifically during coho season. They are very picky. I mean, they're not picky, but they are especially, you know, living in Alaska. So they want to go after those coho salmon.

Nate Hegyi: It’s not just seals that love salmon. People do too. It’s one of the most sought after seafoods in America. Every year, we consume more than 900 million pounds of it. It’s a big business.

But most of us aren’t eating coho salmon… or for that matter other wild-caught Alaskan salmon.

Nowadays, about 70 percent of the salmon you find at the grocery store are Atlantic salmon grown in farms in Europe and Canada.

These farms are essentially giant, floating pens off the coasts of Norway, Scotland and Canada.

Ryley Oliver: they will raise that fish for the entirety of their life from baby all the way up to, um, harvest and to being sold in supermarkets. And they will a lot of times try to accelerate their lifespan a lot faster so that they can have more of an output as well.

Nate Hegyi: As you can imagine, there are some environmental concerns about these farms – which I’m going to into later – but also… many people think that farmed salmon just doesn’t taste as rich and as flavorful as wild-caught salmon.

Case in point… you know how salmon have that beautiful red-orange color? That comes from eating wild critters like krill and small shrimp. But a farmed salmon… they have to artificially color it that way. Otherwise they wind up a dull unsalmony grey.

Wild caught salmon only make up about 30 percent of the market and tends to be at least twice as expensive as farmed salmon.

And up until recently… it was really scarce.

Throughout the early 20th century, rivers that were prime salmon habitat in places like the Pacific Northwest were dammed up.

This blocked crucial salmon migration routes.

At the same time, fisherman were catching and canning salmon willy nilly.

All this created a population crisis by the 1960s. Strict fishing regulations were put in place:

1970s video clip: fishing is only allowed at certain times and certain places. Because if enough fish don’t escape there will be less in the nets in the years to come.

Nate Hegyi: And this was where the idea of “ocean ranching” took off.

States up and down the pacific northwest started funding dozens of hatcheries to essentially grow salmon in warehouses and then release them into the wild. That way, they could boost populations enough to keep them coming to your kitchen table.

But to understand how it works, you first need to understand a wild pacific salmon’s life cycle.

Normally, wild salmon are born in freshwater streams. They live there until they are about a year or two old… and then:

Ryley Oliver: they will head on out to the open ocean and just continue doing what fish do in the open ocean, eating a lot of food, exploring a little bit until one day, you know, something clicks and they are ready to go home, make babies and die.

Nate Hegyi: That’s right. Almost every salmon on earth will return to the exact same stream where it was born.

They’ll fight fast currents, leap over waterfalls, and dodge bears — all so they can get it on fish-style and make more salmon.

Ryley Oliver: they will use their incredible sense of smell. It's a thought that they might have a sense of smell almost a thousand times better than a dog's. Yeah. And so they use that along with Earth's magnetic fields, to get all the way back to their home stream where they were born.

Nate Hegyi: But the quote unquote “Wild salmon” I’m here to see today weren’t born in a stream. they were born in this very hatchery a few years ago.

From there, they were released into the wild. And after a few seasons living it up in the open ocean, that instinctual urge kicked in. They gotta get back to the place where they were born.

That’s why the last journey in the lives of an ocean ranched wild salmon, involves something called a fish ladder.

Ryley Oliver: it is essentially a concrete zigzag. And so the salmon will work their way up each rung and each rung has a rectangle in it that's pushing out water. It is meant to mimic, you know, salmon and wild streams having to jump through and up and over waterfalls. That's exactly what we're trying to mimic here to give them the true, authentic experience.

Nate Hegyi: Why not make it easier for them?

Ryley Oliver: You know, that's a really good question. And, uh, I don't know the answer to that one.

Nate Hegyi: They got they gotta do a little bit of work if they want to. If they want to come back here.

Ryley Oliver: They need to put in the work.

Nate Hegyi: I looked it up later, and it actually makes it harder for other fish that aren’t as strong as salmon to make it up the fish ladder.

Once they do, they’ll be separated by sex and put into these long saltwater pens called raceways. They have nets over them so the salmon can’t jump out.

Ryley Oliver: Some of them have been hanging out for three weeks or so until they get what we call blush, until they turn that bright red color.

Nate Hegyi: This is the gnarliest part of a pacific salmon’s life cycle. Once they enter freshwater, they stop eating. They put all their effort into swimming upstream, making eggs, digging a nest.

Their skin changes different colors. The males develop giant hooked jaws to fight off other males.

In the wild, After they mate… they just don’t have the energy to go on anymore… they start rotting from the outside-in. Their eyes become infected and fall out. Their skin sluffs off. They become what’s known as “zombie salmon.” They are still alive… technically… but they don’t look like it.

When they finally die, their bodies will become food for bears and eagles. They’ll fertilize nearby plants and trees.

But that doesn’t happen to the fish who swim back to this hatchery… because that’s where people step in.

Once the fish change colors, but well before they are zombie salmon, they are lifted by an elevator and slid down a metal shoot to a caged off area.

Ryley Oliver: That caged off area is something we call the dream machine. It is an electro anesthesia machine and it knocks the fish out. Essentially. It's a lot safer for the fish, and it's a lot safer for the humans that are handling them. It really calms them down at their end of life.

Nate Hegyi: So it doesn't kill them. It just calms them down.

Ryley Oliver: Yeah. They're they're pretty much done at that point. It's important to remember they're at the end of their lives anyways. Um, and so this is the end of the line for these fish.

Nate Hegyi: After the fish are zapped by the dream machine, they are brought to the processing room. It kinda looks like a high school lab with a bunch of long silver tables. In there, the females are killed with a blow to the head.

Ryley Oliver: At that point, um, we're able to slice open their bellies and do an egg, take, push all of their eggs. They can have thousands of eggs per female salmon. It'll get pushed down those little chutes into literally a Home Depot five gallon bucket.

Nate Hegyi: Yeah, you heard that right. A home depot bucket. Then the processors take the male salmon and squeeze out all of their seminal fluid - called milt - into that same bucket.

Ryley Oliver: in each bucket there's about 10 to 15 females worth of eggs. And then we're able to squeeze the milk out of the bellies of the males. And there's about 4 to 5 males worth of milt or fish sperm in each bucket.

Nate Hegyi: And you just kind of mix it up and..

Ryley Oliver: Uh, oh, man, magic potion.

Nate Hegyi: I gotta say… Having spent months trying to get pregnant with one human baby… I am jealous of how easy it is for salmon. I mean, I’m not jealous about the dying part… but once some freshwater is added to that bucket, insemination occurs within 30 seconds to a minute. It’s easier than baking a cake.

And as for the mommy and daddy fish - they are sold to seafood processors who turn them into pet food and fertilizer.

The fertilized eggs are put on incubation trays and taken to a cold, dark warehouse. When they hatch, they spend their first few weeks as alvein.

Nate Hegyi: They have something called a yolk sac on their tummies at this point in time. And so they will spend the next few months eating up their yolk sac. But the reason we can't go in there today is because once they've hatched, they are extremely sensitive to light, like it would fast forward their growth like a significant amount, and they would be ready to get put out into salt water way earlier than their life cycle typically would.

Nate Hegyi: What are the wild ones doing if they are so sensitive to light?

Ryley Oliver: they are burrowed in. They're burrowed, hiding in rocks, hiding in mud. Um, um, a female salmon makes a nest called a red REDD. And so she will lay all of her eggs in that red. And then a random male will come by and spread all of his milt and hopefully fertilize those eggs. Um, the male and female salmon usually don't meet each other. Wow. Um, well, sometimes, but not always. And, um, from that point they would be hiding out and hatching in those protected redds.

Nate Hegyi: And this is the key difference between true wild salmon, and the ones that grow up here.

In the wild, a baby salmon is at the bottom of the food chain. They are food for trout, for terns, for heron, for river otters. They can die if the river runs dry… or gets too warm… or completely freezes. Ryley told me:

Ryley Oliver: a baby salmon has a 1 to 10% chance of surviving from egg to juvenile when they go out to salt water.

Nate Hegyi: But here in the hatchery:

Ryley Oliver: we're able to take away a lot of those stressors and bring it all the way up to 90 to 95% survival.

Nate Hegyi: And after several months to a year or more, depending on the species of salmon, they are released into the wild.

with that leg up, these fish DO GREAT. For instance, there is this one species of salmon – called a chum locally but in grocery stores you’ll see it marketed by the arguably better name “keta salmon.”

This hatchery in Juneau releases millions of them every year.and once they make it to the ocean, where they’re fair game for commercial fisheries… they make up almost 95 percent of the overall chum catch in southeast Alaska.

In fact, Ocean ranched salmon like this account for about a third of all wild catches worldwide.

These hatchery-born fish… they kind of remind me of kids who were born with a silver spoon in their mouths…who went to the best private schools, got MBAs… vs the wild born salmon who toughed it out on the streets and really fought for their spot in the open ocean.

To me, those salmon earned that word… wild. And the other ones:

Nate Hegyi: it just feels like the ones like they're like semi-wild, they're like, they've been given like a, a, a boost.

Ryley Oliver: Yeah, yeah. Might like mess with your morals a little bit or not necessarily morals just like your is this really wild? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I can understand where you're coming from with that. Um, but you know, they do spend majority of their lives out in the ocean and we're just giving them a better boost in the beginning stages of their lives.

Nate Hegyi: While we can quibble about how wild these hatchery fish are, there is one thing that Ryley is adamant about.

these are not farmed fish. Which have developed a pretty bad reputation in recent years. Why?

That’s after the break.

From NHPR, this is Outside/In a show where curiosity and the natural world collide. I’m Nate Hegyi.

It was a couple of brothers in Norway who first figured out how to farm salmon.

They’d catch wild juvenile salmon and then keep them in floating sea cages in the country’s fjords until they grew up.

It was a rousing success, and became a whole business in Norway. but the country needed a market to sell all this salmon – decades of overfishing had killed a lot of the demand.

So in the 1980s, they turned to Japan:

Ian Urbina: it experienced a huge boost in global popularity when the industry smartly realized they should convince sushi sellers to begin putting salmon on sushi.

Nate Hegyi: That is Ian Urbina. He is an investigative journalist who founded the nonprofit Outlaw Ocean Project. He says after salmon became popular in the 80s, Norway and other countries advocated for fish farming as a solution to environmental issues like overfishing.

Ian Urbina: there became the notion that, um, the seas were running out of fish and we should start growing more instead rather than catching it.

Nate Hegyi: They also wanted to turn seafood into a major commodity - along the lines of chicken, beef and pork. But one that was more cost-effective and sustainable.

Ian Urbina: we were running out of, um, land whereas to grow livestock. And we're also running out of viable feed sources for land based livestock like soy. Um, and so food scientists were projecting out 20 or 30 years and realizing, um, we need to expand in places that still have a lot to offer. And the ocean was that.

Nate Hegyi: But, it turns out, industrial sized fish farming came with its own problems.

For one, they are often overcrowded with fish, creating inhumane conditions.

Also, the farmed salmon often escape their net pens by the tens of thousands - they invade local rivers and compete with native fish for food.

Then there’s the pollution:

Ian Urbina: the amount of waste that's produced by the farms is very intense. And that can cause infections in the in the fish themselves and the seafood, which is why antibiotics are often used. And then the runoff that's produced by the the waste is a big worry for those who live around there.

Nate Hegyi: And the latest issue that Ian and his team uncovered has to do with what farmed salmon eat. It’s called fishmeal:

Ian Urbina: and it comes from fish that are caught at sea. Usually what are called forage fish. So big schooling small fish like anchovies, um, that are then ground up, cooked and turned into this powder.

Nate Hegyi: Ian’s team discovered that there are a lot of issues with fishmeal. For one, these forage fish are often caught in loosely regulated waters, like off the coast of the African country of Mauritania.

Ian Urbina: Mauritania is among the fastest growing focal points of fishmeal production in Africa. It's a very unregulated fishery. There's very little science coming off the water to tell us. Is the stock doing well? Is it doing poorly? There's very little finances for the Mauritanian government to actually police its rules.

Nate Hegyi: After these forage fish are caught, they are taken ashore to massive fishmeal plants, where the most common complaint:

Ian Urbina: a complaint that often resulted in civil unrest like strikes and violent demonstrations around the plants was stench. this is a factory that's boiling tens of thousands of tons of rotting fish that's going to smell. And if you're doing it 24 over seven, it's going to produce horrific smoke and lots of nasty wastewater. And a lot of these factories are concentrated in a single area where it's not just one, it's a dozen. And people live there and they can't breathe the air. Their clothes smell awful. The restaurants and beaches go out of business. They're real hidden impacts from stench. That was a big finding.

Nate Hegyi: Fishmeal is also highly combustible. All that decaying fish creates a lot of heat which can start a fire.

Ian Urbina: And we found that in the 80s and 90s and 70s, um, there were dozens upon dozens of serious, serious fires that took ships down, took plants down, killed people until they found this chemical called ethoxyquin a fire retardant. [00:09:44-00:09:50] Thanks, Monsanto. Um, that they sprayed on the fishmeal, which was great. Everyone loved it. It stopped the problem. [00:09:54-00:10:06] Then they realized, oh, Ethoxyquin is a potential carcinogen. Um, and it's ending up in our food. So we got to figure out what to do about that. The EU banned it. U.S. and China haven't.

Nate Hegyi: SO THAT’S FISH FARMING.

OCEAN RANCHING, THE KIND I SAW IN ALASKA, WHERE THE SALMON ARE RAISED IN A TANK BUT RELEASED INTO THE WILD – IT IS FREE OF SOME OF THESE PROBLEMS.

BUT Dozens of studies have found that hatchery-born fish also have negative impacts on wildborne fish.

Take the pink salmon.

It’s a species of ocean-rancched salmon raised by some hatcheries in Alaska. Tens of millions of them are released every year. While most of them go back to those hatcheries, some strays have colonized other rivers, pushing out other species of wildborne salmon and reducing genetic diversity.

Then… there is the food these hatchery salmon are eating. It’s… you guessed it… fishmeal.

But maybe not all fishmeal is created equal, I thought.

So After I talked with Ian, I sent an email to Ryley Oliver at the hatchery asking where they source their food. She told me it was from a sustainable company called “Bio-Oregon.”

Hopping on their website, they tout that they are the first company in North America to receive a Best Aquaculture Practices certification.

Is that something that holds water? Ian – along with other environmental watchdogs, say no.

Ian Urbina: No. Unfortunately not. These programs are deeply flawed for lots of reasons. One is that they're, they're a pay to play kind of system where they're giving gold stars to folks who pay for them. And so they don't tend to have much in the way of teeth, um, and vetting who's in and who's out.

Nate Hegyi: Ian also says the companies that dole out these kind of third-party certifications don’t really monitor the whole supply chain.

Ian Urbina: Are you checking the ships that provided the raw material that went to the fishmeal? Are you checking the plants? Are you checking sustainability at each of them? God forbid. Are you also checking worker rights at either of them? The answer tends to be no, no, no, no, we're just checking at the farm. [00:19:24-00:19:26] And are they following hygienic practices? [00:19:32-00:19:59] So it gives the the public a really false sense of security on things that they're asking one question and they think they're getting an answer, but it's not actually the answer that you're seeking.

Nate Hegyi: I checked in for comment from Bio-Oregon on their fish food. I didn’t hear back, but on their website they say they are trying to reduce their reliance on fishmeal by partially substituting it with vegetable proteins in their fish food.

So what is our takeaway here? I mean, these stories always kind of bum me out. Here’s a thing that I love - salmon - but when I go down the rabbit hole I find all these problematic things. And Ian acknowledges this

Ian Urbina: honestly, I think that if you brought this level of rigor to any modern product, you're going to find really bad stuff in the supply chain.

Nate Hegyi: So what’s a guy to do? When I asked Ian what he does he saidd… he’s a vegetarian

Ian Urbina: I'm a bad vegetarian. Um, so I mostly don't eat meat and seafood except when I do, which is not often, but I love, uh, shrimp, I love calamari, I love the taste of the stuff, but I try not to eat animal protein to the extent that I can. Um, uh, so because I think just the, the world will be better off if there's less of that. That’s just my own personal opinion.

Nate Hegyi: I mean, fair. But here’s the thing – most Americans eat meat. So is there any guidance Ian has for folks who don’t wanna give salmon?

Ian Urbina: I think one rule of thumb is the shorter the supply chain, the less places there is to hide bad stuff, hide hidden costs that are offset on the global south. So things that are caught locally are going to just by definition, have much less risk of forced labor, of climate impact of all these things because they're local. And we know here and this is not a buy America kind of ideological point I'm making. It's a more system analysis point about shorter chains or just less links and less place to hide costs. Um, and that I think is also a rule of thumb that's safe to follow in general.

Nate Hegyi: And hopefully catching it yourself is…

Ian Urbina: Yeah that’s as local as it gets

Nate Hegyi: I’m not gonna sit here and to tell how to eat… but I think it’s good to know what we’re eating.

When you see “wild caught” at the grocery store, you might have an idea in your head. But that’s not necessarily how it looks in real life. Even the salmon I catch from some cold, glacier-fed stream in Alaska… isn’t what it seems.

<<cast>>

Nate Hegyi: But I guess everything we eat comes at a cost.

So right now… wild or not-so-wild, fishmeal or no fishmeal… I might as well enjoy the process of reeling in my own dinner.

<<fishing line spins out, MUX>>

Nate Hegyi: That is it for today’s episode. It was reported and mixed by me, your host, Nate Hegyi. It was edited by NHPR’s director of podcasts, Taylor Quimby.

And hey before you press pause and skip to the next episode – I got a trivia question for you. What is the nickname of the most abundant salmon in the world?

No google! First person to email us the answer, we’ll give you a shoutout in our next episode. Our email is outsidein@nhpr.org

And if you want ad-free episodes of Outside/In, you can join our Patreon. $5 a month to support the show. Link in the show notes.

Our team includes Marina Henke, Felix Poon, Justine Paradis and Jessica Hunt.

Music came from Lennon Hutton, Sulu, Blue Saga, Rebecca Mardal, Jake and Jake, Jobi, Hennie Hun, Franzi, and Beyza.

Outside/In is a production of New Hampshire Public Radio.

November 18, 2026 /Nate Hegyi
batch 14
fbq('track', 'ViewContent');
  • Newer
  • Older

Powered by Squarespace